Hello Allyson, I’m so glad this worked for the toilet! I’d love to begin to see the following pics! Indeed, I do think This is able to work very well about Beforehand painted Wooden. Just ensure it’s clean up initial, so you should be good to go. Chris and Lexi http://waylonkieau.bloguetechno.com/what-paint-to-use-for-cabinets-Options-28509710